|
奥地利 |
|
|
案件 |
Lederbauer, 1454/2006 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2007年7月13日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十四条第1款 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括补偿。 以往后续资料：A/63/40 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年12月19日 委员会的《意见》以英文原文和德文在奥地利联邦总理办公厅的网站发布，也散发给了所有涉案机关和机构。2014年1月1日起，奥地利针对行政机关单个决定的法律保护机制经过了重大重组，其指导宗旨是充分履行国际法规定的缔约国义务，特别是公平听证权，包括在合理期限内获相关决策机构听审的权利。设立了联邦行政法院、联邦金融法院和Länder地区行政法院，听审针对行政机关决定的上诉。新体制下，申诉人更便于在法院争取权利，诉讼平均用时预计将大幅缩短，特别是在宪法法院和高等行政法院。 此外，高等行政法院近年来采取了内部措施，因此得以大幅减少待审案件数量和诉讼平均时长。 关于个案措施，提交人已多次面见奥地利政府高级代表，讨论补偿问题。遗憾的是，提交人过度索赔，索赔金额超过欧洲人权法院在类似案件中判定的补偿金，因此未能达成友好解决协议。提交人在联邦检察院启动了诉讼，索赔100,000欧元。其索赔被认定不合理。提交人未就该决定提出上诉。 除司法审查外，奥地利宪法还规定，自认为受到奥地利行政部门不公待遇的，可向奥地利监察员委员会申诉。 转交提交人日期：2015年1月12日 委员会的评估意见： (a)有效补救，包括适足补偿：B1 (b)立法审查：A (c)《意见》的发布：A (d)不重犯：A 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行，待提交人提交评论。 |
|
阿塞拜疆 |
|
|
案件 |
Avadanov, 1633/2007 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2010年10月25日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条，与第二条第3款一并解读 |
|
补救：除其他外，对提交人根据第七条提出的申诉进行公正调查，起诉责任人并提供适当补偿，是为一项有效补救。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年6月16日和2014年10月29日 提交人一案尚未获答复。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年10月21日和2014年11月12日。 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。将向缔约国发出催复函。 |
|
波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那 |
|
|
案件 |
Prutina等，1917/2009,1918/2009,1925/2009和1953/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2013年3月28日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第二条第3款，与第六、第七和第九条一并解读，适用于所有提交人及其失踪亲属；《公约》第二十四条第1款，适用于Alma Čardaković和Samir Čekić |
|
补救：有效补救，包括(a) 缔约国按《2004年失踪人员法》继续努力查明提交人亲属的下落；(b) 按《国家战争罪战略》的要求，在2015年底前将造成其亲属失踪的责任人绳之以法；(c) 取消家人宣布失踪亲属死亡方可申领社会补贴或其他形式补偿的义务；(d) 确保适足补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年7月21日 缔约国当局尚未落实委员会建议的赔偿措施。 提交人表示满意的是，Damjanović先生因参与对其亲属犯下罪行正面临起诉。但缔约国未知会提交人2014年4月以来为调查相关案件采取了哪些具体措施，包括针对第KT-RZ 55/06号案件采取的措施，该案已交另一检察官处理。提交人仍关切的是，缔约国能力不足，难以在2015年底之前处理复杂的刑事案件。 2014年7月4日，Branko Vlačo因危害人类罪获判15年监禁。提交人认为判刑过轻，未考虑其至亲的强迫失踪。至今尚无犯罪者因提交人亲属强迫失踪获刑。 关于法律修正案，提交人强调，拟议社会福利法、战争的平民受害者保护法和有子女家庭保护法修正案已获议会代表院批准，目前须经民族院审议。关于退伍军人及家属权利法修正案的讨论已撤下议程，应在未来数月中重新安排。两项法律的拟议修正案最终获批前，提交人始终认为委员会的建议未落实。 提交人还重申，他们尚未得到补偿。缔约国未明确由哪个机关负责为他们提供补偿。按照义务法，他们将无法获得补偿，因为类似申诉大多被宣布为时效已过。人权与难民部应设立普通民事诉讼以外的有效机制，确保经委员会判定权利受到侵犯的来文提交人获得补偿。 提交人强调，失踪人员法第27条规定，该法生效三年后，1991年4月30日至1996年2月14日期间失踪者应宣布死亡。该规定不合理之处在于，它规定人们必须违背自己意愿宣布至亲死亡，这可能构成一种虐待。 |
|
|
转交缔约国的日期：2014年10月27日 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那 |
|
|
案件 |
Al Gertani, 1955/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2013年11月1日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第九条第1、第2和第4款，以及，如提交人被送往伊拉克，第十七和第二十三条 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括适足补偿。缔约国应在适当条件下释放提交人，或为他提供充分机会，质疑将其拘留的所有依据。将提交人送回原籍国的任何尝试之前，应全面考虑将提交人送往伊拉克的原因，及其家庭生活因此受到的影响。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年6月18日、7月3日和11月24日 缔约国称，提交人仍有可能质疑2011年3月7日行政争议厅下令将其驱逐的决定。为此，他应向法院上诉行政庭提出复议申请。 缔约国还提供资料称提交人与国际恐怖主义有关联，并判定他仍对波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那的国家安全构成威胁，将其驱逐并无障碍。其拘留时长仅与提交人及其拖延遣返进程的努力有关。 缔约国回顾道，当局2014年5月8日决定对提交人进行轻度监控，他随之获准在Banoviči市内有限行动，需按要求于周三、周六和周日前往Banoviči警察局报到，周一、周二、周四和周五向Tuzla地方外事办电话报到。安全部2014年6月2日表示支持该决定，还判定提交人2014年6月2日的上诉没有依据。因此缔约国称，所有适当措施均已采取，委员会要求的补救已落实。 提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年7月14日 缔约国尚未落实委员会的建议。提交人已用尽一切可用补救，包括向宪法法院上诉，该法院驳回了他2010年11月27日对将其遣返提出的质疑。因此在该辖区再次上诉徒劳无益。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年10月23日 委员会的评估意见： (a)有效补救，包括适足补偿：C1 (b)释放(或提供质疑将其拘留的所有依据的充分机会)：A (c)将提交人送回原籍国的任何尝试之前，应全面考虑将提交人送往伊拉克的原因及其家人因此受到的影响：C1 (d)《意见》的公布：A (e)不重犯：C1 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那 |
|
|
案件 |
Rizvanović，1997/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2014年3月21日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第二条第3款，与第六、第七和第九条一并解读，适用于各位提交人及其失踪亲属；第七条，单独并与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于各位提交人 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括适当补偿。缔约国应继续努力查明Mensud Rizvanović的下落并于2015年底之前将其失踪的责任人导致绳之以法。还应修订规定强迫失踪受害者亲属宣布受害者死亡方可申领社会补贴和赔偿的现行法律。 |
|
|
无以往后续资料 |
|
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年8月11日 失踪人员局已向71人提供资料，说明采取了哪些措施寻找其失踪家人。11起案件已结案，即挖掘、指认、或多数情况下掩埋了失踪人员。 缔约国还介绍了为设立失踪人员家庭扶持基金采取的措施。这方面，《失踪人员法》修正案仍有待民族院审议。此外，Republika Srpska政府成立了行动小组，试图按《失踪人员法》加快找寻失踪人员的工作。 委员会的《意见》已经翻译并在人权与难民部网站发布。还向全国有关单位散发了《意见》。 提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年10月16日 提交人之夫仍下落不明。检察官办公室尚未另行立案，2015年底之前恐怕极难立案。失踪人员亲属支助基金尚未成立。基金即便成立，也仅提供社会援助而不提供妥善赔偿。缔约国尚未修订规定强迫失踪受害者亲属仅在获法院决定后才有权理赔的法律。 缔约国应设立一个类似现有机制的机制，执行欧洲人权法院的决定，或与提交人达成确保其获得充足公正补偿的专门协议。 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年12月4日 2014年7月，战争罪专司的检察官设立了关于提交人亲属的第T20 0 KTARZ 0009129 14号案件。2014年10月，检察官办公室下令国家调查和保护局采取行动收集证据。 正在努力加速起诉进程。司法部2014年6月已批准新招募13名检察官，检察官办公室的能力有所增强。 失踪人员局试图联系提交人亲属未果。如有任何新发现将通知提交人。
|
|
喀麦隆 |
|
|
案件 |
Afuson Njaru, 1353/2005 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2007年3月19日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条、第九条第1和第2款及第十九条第2款，与第二条第3款一并解读 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括(a) 及时起诉导致提交人被捕和受到虐待的责任人并予以定罪；(b) 保护免遭安全部队成员威胁和/或恐吓；(c) 有效赔偿，包括充分补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年11月28日 缔约国未履行及时有效调查、起诉侵犯行为责任人并予以定罪的义务，也未落实委员会的《意见》。提交人重申自己受到威胁并遭受恐吓行为，这些行为未获调查。缔约国未能确保未来不再发生类似侵犯行为。缔约国提供的补偿不符和提交人遭受的损害。提交人强调，补偿金数额方面缔约国不应有酌处权。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年12月2日 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
喀麦隆 |
|
|
案件 |
Akwanga, 1813/2008 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年3月22日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条、第十条第1和第2款、第九条第2至第4款和第十四条 |
|
补救：有效补救，应包括审议提交人的判刑，同时给予《公约》规定的保障，调查指控所称事件并起诉责任人，同时提供充足赔偿，包括补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
|
哥伦比亚 |
|
|
案件 |
Bonilla Lerma, 1611/2007 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年7月26日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十四条第1款 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括适足补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/68/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年9月24日 提交人申请补偿金仍未获答复，他作为难民身在哥斯达黎加，无法返回哥伦比亚，因为2005年致使他和家人逃离哥伦比亚的风险仍未消除。 |
|
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年12月5日 部门间人权问题与国际人权法委员会已注意到提交人的论据，并将在做出决定后告知委员会。 转交提交人日期：2014年12月10日 委员会的评估意见： (a)补救：C1 (b)《意见》的公布：无资料 (c)不重犯：C1 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
丹麦 |
|
|
案件 |
X.，2007/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2014年3月26日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括充分考虑提交人关于遣返厄立特里亚后遭受有悖第七条的待遇的风险的说法。 |
|
|
无以往后续资料 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年9月18日 委员会的《意见》转交后，难民上诉委员会决定重新审理提交人的庇护案件。委员会在2014年5月27日的决定中决定依《丹麦外国人法》第七条第2款为提交人发放居留证。提交人持有居留证，因此将不会被遣返厄立特里亚。 《意见》已发布于外交部网站。 转交提交人日期：2014年10月29日 委员会的评估意见： (a)有效补救，包括考虑申请：A (b)《意见》的公布：A (c)不重犯：无资料 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行，有待提交人确认收到居留证。将向提交人发送催复函。 |
|
法国 |
|
|
案件 |
J.O.，1620/2007 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年3月23日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十四条第2和第5款，与第二条一并解读 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括审议提交人的判刑和适当补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年6月16日 缔约国尚未向提交人提供有效且可落实的补救。 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
法国 |
|
|
案件 |
Cochet, 1760/2008 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年10月21日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十五条第1款 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括适当补偿。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年6月30日 缔约国似乎无意落实《意见》。法国政府完全可以按有争议的决定退还提交人的付款。 |
|
|
转交缔约国的日期：2014年11月4日 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
法国 |
|
|
案件 |
Singh, 1928/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2013年7月19日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十八条 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括参照《公约》规定的缔约国义务重新审议提交人更新护照的申请，修订相关规则及实际适用。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年6月3日 缔约国重申，考虑到安全风险和打击欺诈的需要，本国无意变更国内行政体制，该体制符合《欧洲人权公约》。 转交提交人日期：2014年6月13日 委员会的评估意见： (a)补救：C1 (b)《意见》的公布：C2 (c)不重犯：C2 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
哈萨克斯坦 |
|
|
案件 |
Israil, 2024/2011 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年10月31日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第九条第1款，与第二条第3款(甲)项一并解读，第六和第七条，单独并与第二条一并解读 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括适足补偿。请缔约国出台有效措施，同接收国合作，监控提交人的处境并定期向委员会提供关于提交人处境的最新资料。 无以往后续资料 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年11月3日 哈萨克斯坦驻中国大使馆提供的资料表明，提交人2014年5月获释出狱。将提供详细资料。 转交提交人日期：2014年11月11日 委员会的评估意见： (a)补偿：C1 (b)监控提交人的处境的有效措施：B2 (c)《意见》的公布：无资料 (d)不重犯：无资料 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
哈萨克斯坦 |
|
|
案件 |
Valetov, 2104/2011 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2014年3月17日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括同接收国合作，提供适当补偿并采取监控提交人处境的有效措施。 无以往后续资料 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年11月4日 哈萨克斯坦驻吉尔吉斯斯坦大使馆代表2014年10月8日前往比什凯克拘留所探视提交人，并同其律师通话。吉尔吉斯斯坦Shuiski区法院已审议提交人的刑事案件。 提交人目前同6名囚犯一道关押在116号牢房。探视时，他对狱方提供的食物、设施和医疗服务表示满意。 |
|
|
委员会的评估意见： (a)补偿：C1 (b)监控提交人处境的有效措施：B2 (c)《意见》的公布：无资料 (d)不重犯：无资料 提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年12月11日 委员会的建议尚未得到落实。提交人尚未得到适当补偿，因目前正在还押候审，也无法向法院申请补偿。 提交人还受到阻止，无法就将其引渡至吉尔吉斯斯坦一事向哈萨克斯坦大使馆代表提出申诉。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年12月18日 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
立陶宛 |
||
|
案件 |
Paksas, 2155/2012 |
|
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2014年3月25日 |
|
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第二十五条(乙)和(丙)项 |
|
|
补救：有效补救，包括审议终身剥夺参选总统或担任总理或部长的权利的判决。 |
||
|
无以往后续资料 |
||
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年10月7日 委员会《意见》已在立陶宛政府驻欧洲人权法院办事处官方网站上发布。 2014年5月13日，立陶宛议会成立了专门委员会，负责恢复罗兰达斯•帕克萨斯总统的公民权利和政治权利。委员会2014年9月24日做出结论，其中提出多项建议，主要是审议《宪法》和弹劾程序。近期可提出为提交人提供有效补救，包括审议终身剥夺参选总统或担任总理或部长的权利的判决，并确保采取措施避免未来发生类似侵犯行为的宪法修正案。 另考虑到负责执行欧洲人权法院2011年1月6日对帕克萨斯诉立陶宛一案的决定的工作组以及2012年9月5日判决应修订宪法以使其符合欧洲法律的宪法法院提出的建议，提出了相关宪法修正案，作为修订《宪法》第56条的法律草案(关于参选议会的条件)。该法仍在审议和讨论中。鉴于这些进展，预计不久即可向议会提交新起草的考虑到委员会《意见》的宪法修正案。 委员会的评估意见： (a)审议终身剥夺提交人参选总统或担任总理或部长的权利的判决：B2 (b)《意见》的公布：A (c)不重犯：B2
|
|
尼泊尔 |
|
|
案件 |
Sharma, 1469/2006；Giri, 1761/2008；Maharjan, 1863/2009；Sedhai, 1865/2009 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
Sharma, 2008年10月28日；Giri, 2011年3月24日；Maharjan, 2012年7月19日；Sedhai, 2012年7月19日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
Sharma：《公约》第七、第九、第十条和第二条第3款，与第七、第九和第十条一并解读，适用于提交人之夫；第七条，单独并与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于提交人本人 Giri：《公约》第七、第九和第十条第1款，与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于提交人；第七条，与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于提交人之妻及二人的两个子女 Maharjan：《公约》第七、第九和第十条第1款，单独并与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于提交人；第七条，与第二条第3款一并解读，适用于提交人之妻及其父母 Sedhai：《公约》第二条第3款，与第六条第1款、第七、第九条和第十条第1款一并解读，适用于提交人之夫；第二条第3款，与第七条一并解读，适用于提交人及其两个子女 |
|
补救 Sharma 有效补救，包括彻底有效调查提交人之夫的失踪及下落，如在世则立即释放，通过调查获取充分资料，就提交人之夫及提交人和家人遭受的侵犯行为为提交人和家人提供适足补偿。 Giri 有效补救，确保彻底认真调查提交人遭受的酷刑和虐待，起诉并惩处责任人，为提交人及家人遭受的侵犯行为提供适足补偿。同时，缔约国应确保提交人及家人免遭报复恐吓行为。 |
|
|
Maharjan 有效补救，(a) 确保彻底认真调查提交人遭受的酷刑和虐待；(b) 起诉并惩处责任人；(c) 为提交人及家人遭受的侵犯行为提供适足补偿；(d)修订缔约国的法律，使之符合《公约》，包括修订和延长《有关酷刑的补偿法案》中酷刑或获释35天内提出申诉的法定期限；(e) 颁布法律，定义酷刑并将其入刑；(f) 废除所有准许指控所称酷刑和强迫失踪行为犯罪者有罪不罚的法律。同时，缔约国应确保提交人及家人免遭报复或恐吓。 Sedhai 有效补救，包括(a)彻底有效调查Sedhai先生失踪一案；(b) 为提交人及家人提供关于调查结果的详细资料；(c) 如Sedhai先生仍被隔离监禁，立即将其释放；(d)如Sedhai先生已故，将其遗体转交家人；(e) 起诉，审判并惩处责任人犯下的侵犯行为；(f)为提交人及其子女遭受的侵犯行为提供适足补偿，如Sedhai先生仍在世，也为他提供补偿。 以往后续资料：A/68/40和A/69/40 提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年7月10日 提交人的律师称，2014年4月通过《失踪人员调查、真相与和解委员会法》后，尼泊尔执行委员会《意见》的环境大幅恶化(2014年)。 该法设立了两个跨国司法机制：真相与和解委员会与失踪人员调查委员会。该法案适用于所有涉及冲突期间犯下的严重侵犯人权的行为的案件，并将这些案件转交两委员会或其中之一审理。该法的某些要点不符合人权标准。具体而言，该法(a) 在开展有效刑事调查和将犯罪者绳之以法、就严重侵犯人权和严重违反国际人道主义法律的行为提出大赦建议并协助受害者与犯罪者“和解”方面授予当局宽泛的酌处权；(b) 未保障委员的独立和公正；(c) 不承认提交人及家人获得赔偿等有效补救的权利。 目前实行的该法将阻碍这些案件中《意见》的执行，侵犯了《公约》规定的提交人的权利。 Sharma、Giri和Sedhai 律师请委员会呼吁缔约国立即对发现的侵犯行为开展刑事调查并修订该法，以确保所犯罪行的责任人能够并将被绳之以法。 Maharjan 2014年4月，Maharjan先生获赔150,000尼泊尔卢比(约1,500美元)“临时赔偿”，此前他曾按适用于所有冲突期间遭绑架的受害者的“普通赔偿”政策获赔25,000尼泊尔卢比(约250美元)。这一初步措施令人欢迎，但对于Maharjan先生及家人的遭遇远非适足补偿，Maharjan先生及家人受到的身心伤害包括：遭酷刑和任意拘留超过一年，其中10个月为隔离监禁；家人因其失踪和所受酷刑而遭受苦难；他对自己农场的全部投资，约500,000尼泊尔卢比(5,000美元)；身为教师生计来源持续损失。 转交缔约国的日期：Maharjan和Sedhai：2014年10月21日；Sharma和Giri：2014年10月22日。 委员会的决定：四个案件的后续对话正在进行。 |
|
俄罗斯联邦 |
|
|
案件 |
Khoroshenko, 1304/2004 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年3月29日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第六条与第十四条一并解读；第七条、第九条第1至第4款、第十四条第1款和第3款(甲)、(乙)、(丁)、(庚) |
|
补救：有效补救，包括(a)充分彻底调查酷刑和虐待指控并对提交人所遭待遇的责任人启动刑事诉讼；(b) 按《公约》规定的所有保障重新审理；(c) 为提交人提供充足赔偿，包括补偿金。 以往后续资料：A/69/40 提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年7月22日 尚未采取措施为受害者提供有效补救。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年10月29日 委员会的决定：已向缔约国发出意见催复函。后续对话正在进行。 |
|
西班牙 |
|
|
案件 |
Aarrass, 2008/2010 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2014年7月21日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七条 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括(a) 适足补偿其受到侵犯的权利，应考虑到他被引渡至摩洛哥后遭受的酷刑和虐待行为；(b)采取一切可能的措施，同摩洛哥当局合作，以确保有效监督提交人在摩洛哥所受待遇。 无以往后续资料 提交方：提交人的律师 提交日期：2014年9月19日 提交人的律师转交了发表于摩洛哥报刊的两篇文章，文章称Ali Aarrass未曾遭到酷刑。提交人的律师对提交人的安全表示关切。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年11月3日 委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
乌拉圭 |
|
|
案件 |
Peirano Basso, 1887/2009 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2010年10月19日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第十四条第3款(丙)项 |
|
补救：有效补救。缔约国应采取措施，加速审理提交人。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人 提交日期：2014年7月24日 最高法院2014年5月20日吊销了提交人的法律从业执照。提交人认为这侵犯了他被推定无罪的权利，说明法院有所偏倚。 转交缔约国的日期：2014年10月27日 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
乌兹别克斯坦 |
|
|
案件 |
Ismailov, 1769/2008 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2011年3月25日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第九条第2和第3款，第十四条第3款(乙)、(丁)、(戊)、(庚)项 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括按《公约》规定的所有保障重新审理或释放，同时提供适当赔偿，包括补偿金。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：提交人的顾问 提交日期：2014年6月14日、2014年11月4日 未采取措施为受害者提供有效补救。缔约国不准许提交人之夫行使寻求赦免的权利。 缔约国在来文中未提供证明受害者有罪的确凿证据。 提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年5月22日、8月27日和12月3日 提交人之夫被判犯有多项罪行。最高法院认为没有理由修改军事法庭的判决。 提交人之夫多次违反监狱内部规章。他正在接受治疗，目前情况良好。他未遭身心压力，也未向教改部门提出申诉。 转交提交人日期：2014年10月23和29日，12月10日。 委员会的评估意见： (a)重新审理或释放：C1 (b)适当赔偿：C1 (c)《意见》的公布：无资料 (d)不重犯：C1 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
|
乌兹别克斯坦 |
|
|
案件 |
Musaev, 1914-1915-1916/2009 |
|
《意见》通过日期 |
2012年3月21日 |
|
违反《公约》情况 |
《公约》第七、第九条和第十四条第3款(乙)和(庚)项和第5款 |
|
补救：有效补救，包括对酷刑和虐待的指控进行公正、有效、彻底的调查并对责任人启动刑事诉讼；按《公约》规定的所有保障重新审理受害者或将其释放；充分赔偿受害者赔偿，包括适当补偿金。 |
|
|
以往后续资料：A/69/40 |
|
|
提交方：缔约国 提交日期：2014年6月26日和12月3日 受害者拘留期间得到了充足医疗救助，目前健康状况良好，拘留期间未受任何虐待。他2012至2014年期间获准与亲属相见。未要求请律师。 转交提交人日期：2014年10月21日、12月10日 委员会的评估意见： (a)调查：C1 (b)重新审理或释放，充分赔偿：C2 (c)《意见》的公布：无资料 (d)不重犯：C1 |
|
|
委员会的决定：后续对话正在进行。 |
附件一
人权事务委员会评估收到的缔约国的答复和缔约国采取的行动所用标准
|
评估标准 |
||
|
对答复/行动的满意度 |
||
|
A |
答复基本满意 |
|
|
对答复/行动的部分满意度 |
||
|
B1 |
虽采取了实质行动，但还需增补资料 |
|
|
B2 |
虽采取了初步行动，但还需增补资料 |
|
|
对答复/行动的不满意度 |
||
|
C1 |
虽采取了行动，但并未落实《意见》/建议 |
|
|
C2 |
虽收到答复，但与意见/建议不相关 |
|
|
不与委员会的合作度 |
||
|
D1 |
规定期限内未收到答复，或未答复报告中的任何具体问题 |
|
|
D2 |
发出催复函后未收到答复 |
|
|
所采取的措施与委员会建议相悖 |
||
|
E |
答复显示所采取的措施与委员会的建议/《意见》相悖 |
Annex II
Follow-up activities under the Optional Protocol *
1.The table below provides a complete picture of the follow-up information provided in the replies of States parties to the Views of the Committee in which it concluded that there had been a violation of the Covenant, which were received prior to the 113th session of the Committee (16 March–2 April 2015). It indicates whether the follow-up replies are considered satisfactory or unsatisfactory in terms of their compliance with the Committee’s Views, or whether the dialogue between the State party and the Special Rapporteur for follow-up on Views continues.
2.At its 109th session, the Committee decided, in an effort to have its assessment of follow-up to Views disclosed in a more comprehensive, structured and transparent manner, to include an indication of its current assessment of the follow-up status in cases in which submissions were received from the parties during the reporting period. Decisions to have the follow-up dialogue closed or suspended are also indicated in the table below.
3.Follow-up information provided by States parties and by petitioners or their representatives subsequent to the previous interim report on follow-up to Views (CCPR/C/112/3) is published in the present report. Reports on follow-up to Views are no longer part of the Committee’s annual reports, but will be prepared periodically by the Special Rapporteur for follow-up on Views, adopted by the Committee during its October and March sessions and published on the website of the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
|
State party and number of cases with violation |
Communication number, author and relevant Committee report |
Follow-up response received from State party |
No response |
Follow-up dialogue ongoing |
|||
|
Algeria (38) |
992/2001, BousroualA/61/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
1085/2002, TarightA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1172/2003, MadaniA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1173/2003, BenhadjA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1196/2003, BoucherfA/61/40 |
XA/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1297/2004, Medjnoune A/61/40 |
XA/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1327/2004, GriouaA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1328/2004, KimoucheA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1439/2005, AberA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1495/2006, MadouiA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1588/2007, BenazizaA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1753/2008, RakikA/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1779/2008, MezineA/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1780/2008, Aouabdia et al.A/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1781/2008, BerzigA/67/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1791/2008, SahbiA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1796/2008, ZerrouguiA/69/40 |
Not due yet |
X |
|||||
|
1798/2008, Azouz A/69/40 |
Not due yet |
X |
|||||
|
1806/2008, SaadounA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1807/2008, MechaniA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1811/2008, Djebbar and ChihoubA/67/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1831/2008, Larbi A/69/40 |
Not due yet |
X |
|||||
|
1874/2009, Mihoubi A/69/40 |
Not due yet |
X |
|||||
|
1884/2009, Faraoun A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1889/2009, MaroufA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1899/2009, Lakhdar-ChaouchA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1900/2009, MehalliA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1905/2009, OuaghlissiA/67/40 |
X |
||||||
|
CCPR/C/111/D/1924/2010, Boudehane CCPR/C/111/D/1931/2010, Bouzenia CCPR/C/111/D/1964/2010, Fedsi CCPR/C/111/D/1974/2010, Bouzaout CCPR/C/112/D/2026/2011, Sassene CCPR/C/112/D/2083/2011, Kroumi CCPR/C/112/D/2086/2011, Ayache CCPR/C/112/D/2098/2011, Ammari CCPR/C/112/D/2117/2011, Louddi CCPR/C/112/D/2132/2012, Kerouane |
|||||||
|
Angola (2) |
711/1996, Dias A/55/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
1128/2002, MarquesA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Argentina (4) |
400/1990, Mónaco de GallichioA/50/40 |
XA/51/40 |
X |
||||
|
1458/2006, González et al.A/66/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1608/2007, L.M.R.A/66/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1610/2007, L.N.P.A/66/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/68/40 |
||||||
|
Australia (32) |
560/1993, A. A/52/40 |
XA/53/40, A/55/40, A/56/40 |
X |
||||
|
900/1999, C.A/58/40 |
XA/58/40, CCPR/C/80/FU/1, A/60/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
930/2000, Winata et al.A/56/40 |
XCCPR/C/80/FU/1, A/57/40, A/60/40 A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
941/2000, YoungA/58/40 |
XA/58/40, A/60/40, A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1014/2001, Baban et al.A/58/40 |
XA/60/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1020/2001, Cabal and PasiniA/58/40 |
XA/58/40, CCPR/C/80/FU/1 |
||||||
|
1036/2001, Faure A/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1050/2002, Rafie and SafdelA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 and A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1069/2002, BakhitiyariA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1157/2003, ColemanA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1184/2003, BroughA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1255, 1256, 1259, 1260, 1266, 1268, 1270 and 1288/2004, Shams, Atvan, Shahrooei, Saadat, Ramezani, Boostani, Behrooz and SefedA/62/40 |
XA/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1324/2004, ShafiqA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 and A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1347/2005, DudkoA/62/40 |
XA/63/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1442/2005, KwokA/65/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
X A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1629/2007, FardonA/65/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of unsatisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1557/2007, Nystrom et al.A/66/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of unsatisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/68/40). |
|||||||
|
1635/2007, TillmanA/65/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of unsatisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1885/2009, HorvathA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
CCPR/C/112/D/1968/2010, Blessington and Elliot CCPR/C/112/D/1973/2010, Griffiths |
X X |
||||||
|
2094/2011, Abdul Gafoor, Faleel Khan et al. A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
2136/2012, Mofis, Mohammad Mufis et al. A/69/40 |
|||||||
|
CCPR/C/113/D/1875/2009, M.G.C.CCPR/C/113/D/1937/2010, Leghaei |
XX |
||||||
|
Austria (4) |
415/1990, PaugerA/57/40 |
XA/47/40, A/52/40, A/66/40 |
|||||
|
716/1996, PaugerA/54/40 |
XA/54/40, A/55/40, A/57/40, A/66/40, CCPR/C/80/FU/1 |
||||||
|
965/2001, KarakurtA/57/40 |
XA/58/40, CCPR/C/80/FU/1, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1454/2006, LederbauerA/62/40 |
XA/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Azerbaijan (2) |
1633/2007, AvadanovA/66/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1972/2010, Quliyev |
X |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
Belarus (72) |
780/1997, LaptsevichA/55/40 |
XA/56/40, A/57/40 |
X |
||||
|
814/1998, PastukhovA/58/40 |
XA/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
886/1999, BondarenkoA/58/40Case closed (ninety-second session) |
XA/59/40, A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
||||||
|
887/1999, LyashkevichA/58/40Case closed (ninety-second session) |
XA/59/40, A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
||||||
|
921/2000, DergachevA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
927/2000, SvetikA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/61/40 and A/62/40 |
X |
XA/62/40 |
||||
|
1009/2001, ShchetkoA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1022/2001, VelichkinA/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1039/2001, Boris et al.A/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1047/2002, Sinitsin, LeonidA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1100/2002, BandazhewskyA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1178/2003, SmantserA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1207/2003, MalakhovskyA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1226/2003, KorneenkoA/68/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1274/2004, KorneenkoA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
|||||
|
1296/2004, BelyatskyA/62/40 |
XA/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1311/2004, OsiyukA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1316/2004, GrybA/67/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1354/2005, SudalenkoA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1377/2005, KatsoraA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1383/2005, Katsora et al.A/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1390/2005, KorebaA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1392/2005, LukyanchikA/65/40 |
X A/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1502/2006, MarinichA/65/40 |
X A/66/40 |
||||||
|
1553/2007, Korneenko and MilinkevichA/64/40 |
X A/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1592/2007, PichuginaA/69/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1604/2007, ZalesskayaA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1750/2008, SudalenkoA/67/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1772/2008, BelyazekaA/67/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1773/2008, Kozulina |
X X |
XX A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1784/2008, SchumilinA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1785/2008, OleshkevishA/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1787/2008, Kovsh (Abramova)A/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1790/2008, Govsha et al.A/68/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1820/2008, KrassovskayaA/67/40 |
X |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1808/2008, KovalenkoA/69/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1830/2008, PivonosA/68/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1835-1837/2008, Yasinovi chA/68/40 |
X |
XX |
|||||
|
1836/2008, KatsoraA/68/40 |
X |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1838/2008, TulzhenkovaA/67/40 |
X |
XXX |
|||||
|
1839/2008, KomarovskyA/69/40 |
XX |
||||||
|
1851/2008, Sekerko A/69/40 |
X |
XX |
|||||
|
1864/2009, Kirsanov A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1867/2009, 1936, 1975, 1977-1891/2010, 2010/2010, LevinovA/68/40 |
X |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1903/2009, YoubkoA/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1906/2010, Yuzepchuk |
X |
||||||
|
1910/2009, Zhuk A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1919-1920/2009, Protsko & Tolchin A/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1929/2010, Lozenko CCPR/C/112/D/1933/2010, Aleksandrov CCPR/C/111/D/1934/2010, Bazarov |
XX X X |
X X |
|||||
|
1948/2010, Turchenyak A/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1952/2010, Symonik CCPR/C/111/D/1976/2010, Kuznetsov et al. CCPR/C/111/D/1985/2010, Koktish CCPR/C/111/D/1986/2010, Kozlov CCPR/C/112/D/1987/2010, Stambrovsky CCPR/C/111/D/1991/2010, Volchek CCPR/C/111/D/1993/2010, Mikhailovskaya and Volchek CCPR/C/112/D/1999/2010, Evrezov, Nepomnyaschikh, Polyakov, and Rybchenko |
XX X X X X |
XX X X X X X X X X |
|||||
|
CCPR/C/112/D/2029/2011, Praded CCPR/C/111/D/2030/2010, Poliakov |
X X |
||||||
|
2065/2011, KvashaA/68/40 CCPR/C/111/D/2103/2010, Poliakyov CCPR/C/112/D/2114/2011, Sudalenko |
X X |
||||||
|
2120/2011, KovalevA/68/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2153/2012, Kalyakin CCPR/C/112/D/2156/2012, Nepomnyaschikh CCPR/C/112/D/2165/2012, Pinchuk CCPR/C/113/D/1949/2010, Kozlov et al. CCPR/C/113/D/1992/2010, Sudalenko CCPR/C/113/D/2013/2010, Grishkovtsov |
X X X X |
||||||
|
Belgium (1) |
1472/2006, SayadiA/64/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Benin (1) |
CCPR/C/111/D/2055/2011, Zinsou |
||||||
|
Bolivia (PlurinationalState of) (1) |
176/1984, PeñarrietaA/43/40 |
XA/52/40 |
X |
||||
|
Bosnia and Herzegovina (9) |
1917-1918-1925/2008, Prutina et al.A/68/40 1955/2010, Al-Gertani A/69/40 CCPR/C/111/D/1956/2010, Duric CCPR/C/112/D/1966/2010, Hero CCPR/C/112/D/1970/2010, Kožljak |
X X X |
|||||
|
1997/2010, Rizvanović et alA/69/40 CCPR/C/111/D/2003/2010, Selimovi ć et al. CCPR/C/113/D/2022/2011, Hamulić et al. CCPR/C/113/D/2028/2011 , I č ić et al. |
X X X |
||||||
|
Bulgaria (1) |
2073/2011, Naidenova et al. A/68/40 |
||||||
|
Burkina Faso (1) |
1159/2003, Sankara et al.A/61/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the Committee’s recommendation. (A/63/40) |
XA/63/40 |
|||||
|
Cameroon (8) |
458/1991, MukongA/49/40 |
XA/52/40 |
X |
||||
|
630/1995, Mazou The State party reported that it had reinstated the author to the judiciary and that it had offered him compensation, which he refused to accept because he considered it to be inadequate. The follow-up dialogue in the case was closed as the Committee deemed that the State party had complied with the Views (A/59/40). |
XA/57/40 |
||||||
|
1134/2002, Gorji-DinkaA/60/40 |
X A/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1186/2003, TitiahongoA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1353/2005, AfusonA/62/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
1397/2005, EngoA/64/40 |
XA/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1813/2008, AkwangaA/66/40 CCPR/C/112/D/1965/2010, Monika |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Canada (15) |
27/1978, PinkneyFourteenth sessiona |
X |
X |
||||
|
167/1984, Lubicon Lake BandA/45/40 |
XA/59/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
|||||
|
694/1996, WaldmanA/55/40 |
XA/55/40, A/56/40, A/57/40, A/59/40, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
829/1998, JudgeA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/60/40 |
XA/60/40 |
|||||
|
1051/2002, AhaniA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/61/40 |
XbA/60/40 |
|||||
|
1465/2006, KabaA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1467/2006, DumontA/65/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/66/40, A/67/40, A/68/40 |
||||||
|
1544/2007, HamidaA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1763/2008, Pillai et al.Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (see A/68/40). |
XA/67/40 |
||||||
|
1792/2008 DauphinA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1881/2009, MasihA/69/40 |
Not due |
X |
|||||
|
1898/2009, Choudhary A/69/40 |
Not due |
X |
|||||
|
1912/2009, Thuraisamy A/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1959/2010, WarsameA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
CCPR/C/113/D/2091/2011, A.H. G. |
X |
||||||
|
Central African Republic (1) |
1587/2007 MamourA/64/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Colombia (16) |
45/1979, Suárez de GuerreroFifteenth sessiona |
XA/52/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
46/1979, Fals Borda Sixteenth sessiona |
XA/52/40 |
X |
|||||
|
64/1979, Salgar de MontejoFifteenth sessiona |
XA/52/40, A/68/40 |
X(A/68/40) |
|||||
|
161/1983, Herrera Rubio Thirty-first sessionc |
XA/52/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
181/1984, Sanjuán Arévalo brothersA/45/40 |
XA/52/40, A/64/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
195/1985, Delgado PáezA/45/40 |
XA/52/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
514/1992, FeiA/50/40 |
XA/51/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
612/1995, ArhuacosA/52/40 |
X A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
687/1996, Rojas GarcíaA/56/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
778/1997, Coronel et al.A/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
848/1999, Rodríguez Orejuela,A/57/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
859/1999, Jiménez VacaA/57/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40, A/61/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1298/2004, BecerraA/61/40 |
XA/62/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1361/2005, CasadiegoA/62/40 |
XA/63/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1611/2007, Bonilla LermaA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1641/2007, Calderón BrugesA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Côte d’Ivoire (1) |
1759/2008, TraoréA/67/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Croatia (2) |
727/1996, ParagaA/56/40 |
XA/56/40, A/58/40 |
X |
||||
|
1510/2006, Vojnović, A/64/40 |
XA/65/40, A/66/40 |
||||||
|
Czech Republic (27)d |
516/1992, Simunek et al.A/50/40 |
XA/51/40, A/57/40, A/58/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
X |
||||
|
586/1994, AdamA/51/40 |
XA/51/40, A/53/40, A/54/40, A/57/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
747/1997, Des Fours WalderodeA/57/40 |
XA/57/40, A/58/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
757/1997, PezoldovaA/58/40 |
XA/60/40, A/61/40 andA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
765/1997, FábryováA/57/40 |
XA/57/40, A/58/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
823/1998, CzerninA/60/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
857/1999, Blazek et al.A/56/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
945/2000, MarikA/60/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
946/2000, PateraA/57/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1054/2002, KrizA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1445/2006, PolacekA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1448/2006, KohoutekA/63/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1463/2006, GratzingerA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1479/2006, PersanA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1484/2006, LnenickaA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1485/2006, VlcekA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1488/2006, SüsserA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1491/2006, Fürst Blücher von WahlstattA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1497/2006, PreissA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1508/2006, AmundsonA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1586/2007, LangeA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1533/2006, OndrackaA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1563/2007, JünglingováA/67/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1581/2007, DrdaA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1615/2007, ZavrelA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1742/2007, GschwindA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1847/2008, Klain and Klain A/67/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
Democratic Republic of the Congo (15)e |
16/1977, MbengeEighteenth sessionc |
X |
X |
||||
|
90/1981, LuyeyeNineteenth sessionc |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
124/1982, MutebaTwenty-second sessionc |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
138/1983, Mpandanjila et al.Twenty-seventh sessionc |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
157/1983, Mpaka NsusuTwenty-seventh sessionc |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
194/1985, MiangoThirty-first sessionc |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
241/1987, BirindwaA/45/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
242/1987, TshisekediA/45/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
366/1989, KananaA/49/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
542/1993, TshishimbiA/51/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
641/1995, GedumbeA/57/40 |
XA/61/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
933/2000, Mundyo Busyo et al.(68 judges)A/58/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
962/2001, MuleziA/59/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1177/2003, Wenga and ShandweA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1890/2009, KitengeA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
Denmark (4) |
1554/2007, El-HichouA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
||||
|
2007/2010, J.J.M.A/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2243/2013, Husseini CCPR/C/113/D/2001/2010, Q |
X X |
||||||
|
Dominican Republic (2) |
193/1985, GiryA/45/40 |
XA/52/40, A/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
449/1991, MojicaA/49/40 |
XA/52/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Ecuador (2) |
277/1988, Terán JijónA/47/40 |
XA/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
319/1988, Cañón GarcíaA/47/40 |
X |
||||||
|
Equatorial Guinea (3) |
414/1990, Primo EssonoA/49/40 |
A/62/40f |
X |
X |
|||
|
468/1991, Oló BahamondeA/49/40 |
A/62/40f |
X |
X |
||||
|
1152 and 1190/2003, Ndong et al. and Mic AbogoA/61/40 |
A/62/40f |
X |
X |
||||
|
Finland (1) |
779/1997, Äärelä et al.A/57/40 |
XA/57/40, A/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
France (6) |
1620/2007, J.O.A/66/40 |
XA/67/40 |
X |
||||
|
1760/2008, CochetA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1852/2008, SinghA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1876/2009, SinghA/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1928/2010, Singh A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1960/2010, OryA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
Georgia (3) |
626/1995, GelbekhianiA/53/40 |
X A/54/40 |
X |
||||
|
627/1995, DokvadzeA/53/40 |
XA/54/40 |
X |
|||||
|
975/2001, RatianiA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Germany (1) |
1482/2006, GerlachA/63/40 |
XA/64/40 |
X |
||||
|
Ghana (1) |
2177/2012, JohnsonA/69/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Greece (4) |
1070/2002, KouldisA/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
1486/2006, KalamiotisA/63/40 |
X A/64/40A/68/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1558/2007, KatsarisA/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1799/2008, Georgopoulos et al.A/65/40 |
XA/66/40, A/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Guyana (9) |
676/1996, Yasseen and ThomasA/53/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||
|
728/1996, SahadeoA/57/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
811/1998, Mulai, A/59/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
812/1998, PersaudA/61/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
862/1999, Hussain and HussainA/61/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
838/1998, HendriksA/58/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
867/1999, SmarttA/59/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
912/2000, GangaA/60/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
913/2000, ChanA/61/40 |
A/60/40fA/62/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Hungary (3) |
410/1990, PárkányiA/47/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
521/1992, KulominA/51/40 |
XA/52/40 |
X |
|||||
|
852/1999, BorisenkoA/58/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Iceland (1) |
1306/2004, Haraldsson and Sveinsson, A/62/40 Follow-up dialogue closed, with a partly satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
XA/63/40, A/64/40, A/67/40 |
|||||
|
Italy (1) |
699/1996, MalekiA/54/40 |
XA/55/40 |
X |
||||
|
Jamaica (98) |
92 casesg |
X |
|||||
|
695/1996, SimpsonA/57/40 |
XA/57/40, A/58/40, A/59/40, A/63/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
792/1998, HigginsonA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
793/1998, PryceA/59/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
796/1998, ReeceA/58/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
797/1998, LobbanA/59/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
798/1998, HowellA/59/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Kazakhstan (5) |
CCPR/C/111/D/2009/2010, Ilyasov 2024/2011, IsrailA/67/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
2104/2011, ValetovA/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2131/2012, Leven CCPR/C/112/D/2137/2012, Toregozhina |
X |
||||||
|
Kyrgyzstan (15) |
1275/2004, Umetaliev and TashtanbekovaA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
||||
|
1312/2004, LatifulinA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1338/2005, KaldarovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1369/2005, KulovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1402/2005, KrasnovA/66/40 |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1461, 1462, 1476 and 1477/2006, Maksudov, Rakhimov, Tashbaev, PirmatovA/63/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1470/2006, ToktakunovA/66/40 Follow-up dialogue closed with satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/67/40 |
||||||
|
1503/2006, AkhadovA/66/40 |
XA/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1545/2007, GunanA/66/40 |
XA/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1547/2007, TorobekovA/67/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1756/2008, Moidunov and ZhumbaevaA/66/40 CCPR/C/113/D/2054/2011, Ernazarov |
XA/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 X |
|||||
|
Latvia (2) |
884/1999, IgnataneA/56/40 |
XA/57/40 |
|||||
|
1621/2007, RaihmanA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Libya (20) |
440/1990, El-MegreisiA/49/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
1107/2002, El GharA/60/40 |
XA/61/40, A/62/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1143/2002, DernawiA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1295/2004, El AwaniA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1422/2005, El HassyA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1640/2007, El AbaniA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1751/2008, Aboussedra et al.A/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1755/2008, El Hagog JumaaA/67/40 |
|||||||
|
1776/2008, Ali Bashasha and Hussein Bashasha |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1782/2008, AboufaiedA/67/40A/66/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1804/2008, Il KhwildyA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1805/2008, BenaliA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1832/2008, Al KhazmiA/69/40 CCPR/C/111/D/1860/2009, Al Rabassi |
|||||||
|
1880/2009, Nenova et al.A/67/40 CCPR/C/111/D/1882/2009, Al Daquel |
|||||||
|
1913/2009, AbushalaA/68/40 CCPR/C/111/D/1958/2010, El Hojouj et al. CCPR/C/112/D/2046/2011, Hmeed 2006/2010, Almegaryaf and MatarA/69/40 |
X X X |
||||||
|
Lithuania (1) |
2155/2012, Paksas A/69/40 |
||||||
|
Madagascar (4) |
49/1979, MaraisEighteenth sessionc |
X h |
X |
||||
|
115/1982, WightTwenty-fourth sessionc |
X h |
X |
|||||
|
132/1982, JaonaTwenty-fourth sessionc |
X |
X |
|||||
|
155/1983, HammelA/42/40c |
X |
X |
|||||
|
Mauritius (1) |
1744/2007, Narrain et al.A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
Nepal (10) |
1469/2006, SharmaA/64/40 |
XA/64/40, A/66/40, A/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
1761/2008, Giri et al.A/66/40 |
XA/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1863/2009, MaharjanA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1865/2009, Sedhai A/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1870/2009, Sobhraj A/65/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2018/2010, Chaulagain CCPR/C/112/D/2031/2011, Bhandari CCPR/C/112/D/2051/2011, Basnet CCPR/C/112/D/2111/2011, Tripathi et al. CCPR/C/113/D/2000/2010, Katwal |
XA/66/40, A/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 X |
|||||
|
Netherlands (6) |
786/1997, VosA/54/40 |
XA/55/40 |
X |
||||
|
976/2001, DerksenA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1238/2003, Jongenburger VeermanA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1564/2007, X.H.L.A/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1797/2008, MennenA/65/40 CCPR/C/111/D/2097/2011, Timmer |
X |
X |
|||||
|
New Zealand (2) |
1368/2005, BrittonA/62/40 |
XA/63/40 |
X |
||||
|
1512/2006, DeanA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Nicaragua (1) |
328/1988, Zelaya BlancoA/49/40 |
X A/56/40, A/57/40, A/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
Norway (2) |
1155/2003, LeirvagA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
1542/2007, AboushanifA/63/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/65/40 |
||||||
|
Panama (2) |
289/1988, WolfA/47/40 |
XA/53/40 |
X |
||||
|
473/1991, BarrosoA/50/40 |
XA/53/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Paraguay (3) |
1407/2005, AsensiA/64/40 |
XA/65/40, A/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
1828/2008, DomínguezA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1829/2008, Benítez GamarraA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Peru (15) |
202/1986, Ato del AvellanalA/44/40 |
XA/52/40, A/59/40, A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
203/1986, Muñoz HermosaA/44/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of unsatisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/52/40, A/59/40, A/68/40 |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
263/1987, González del RíoA/48/40 |
XA/52/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
309/1988, Orihuela ValenzuelaA/48/40 |
XA/52/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
540/1993, Celis LaureanoA/51/40 |
XA/59/40, A/68/40 |
X A/68/40 |
|||||
|
577/1994, Polay CamposA/53/40 |
XA/53/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
678/1996, Gutiérrez VivancoA/57/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40, A/64/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
688/1996, ArredondoA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
906/1999, Vargas-MachucaA/57/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
981/2001, Gómez CasafrancaA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1058/2002, VargasA/61/40 |
XA/61/40 and A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1125/2002, QuispeA/61/40 |
XA/61/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1126/2002, CarranzaA/61/40 |
XA/61/40, A/62/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1153/2003, K.N.L.H.A/61/40 |
XA/61/40, A/62/40 and A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1457/2006, Poma PomaA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Philippines (11) |
788/1997, CagasA/57/40 |
XA/59/40, A/60/40, A/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
868/1999, WilsonA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/61/40, A/62/40 |
X |
|||||
|
869/1999, Piandiong et al.A/56/40 |
XN/A |
X |
|||||
|
1089/2002, RouseA/60/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||||
|
1320/2004, Pimentel et al.A/62/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of a unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
XA/63/40, A/64/40, A/66/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1421/2005, LarrañagaA/61/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1466/2006, Lumanog and SantosA/63/40 |
XA/65/40, A/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1559/2007, HernandezA/65/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1560/2007, Marcellana and GumanoyA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1619/2007, Pestaño A/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1815/2008, AdonisA/67/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
Portugal (1) |
1123/2002, Correia de MatosA/61/40 |
XA/62/40, A/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
Republic of Korea (12) |
518/1992, SohnA/50/40 |
XA/60/40, A/62/40 |
X |
||||
|
574/1994, KimA/54/40 |
XA/60/40, A/62/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
628/1995, ParkA/54/40 |
XA/54/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
878/1999, KangA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
926/2000, ShinA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/62/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1119/2002, LeeA/60/40 |
XA/61/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1321 and 1322/2004, Yoon,Yeo-Bzum and Choi,Myung-JinA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 and A/63/40A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1593 to 1603/2007, Jung et al.A/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1642-1741/2007, Jeong et al.A/66/40 |
XA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1786/2008, Kim et al.A/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1908/2009, OstavariA/69/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2179/2012, Young-kwan Kim et al. |
X |
||||||
|
Romania (1) |
1158/2003, BlagaA/60/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
712/1996, SmirnovaA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
763/1997, LantsovA/57/40 |
A/58/40, A/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
770/1997, GridinA/55/40 |
A/57/40, A/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
888/1999, TelitsinA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
815/1997, DuginA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
889/1999, ZheikovA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1218/2003, PlatanovA/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1232/2003, PustovalovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1278/2004, ReshnetnikovA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1304/2004, KhoroshenkoA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1310/2004, BabkinA/63/40 |
X A/64/40, A/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1410/2005, Yevdokimov and RezanovA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1447/2006, AmirovA/64/40 |
XA/65/40, A/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1548/2007, KholodovA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1577/2007, UsaevA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1605/2007, ZyuskinA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1628/2007, PavlyuchenkovA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1795/2008, ZhirnovA/69/40 |
X (24/02) |
X |
|||||
|
1856/2008, Sevostyanov A/69/40 |
X (24/02) |
X |
|||||
|
1866/2009, ChebotarevaA/67/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1873/2009, Alekseev A/69/40 |
X (24/02) |
X |
|||||
|
1932/2010, FedotovaA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
2041/2011, Dorofeev 2126/2011, Kesmatulla |
|||||||
|
Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (1) |
806/1998, ThompsonA/56/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
Serbia (1) |
1556/2007, NovakovićA/66/40 |
XA/66/40, A/67/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
Sierra Leone (3) |
839/1998, Mansaraj et al.A/56/40 |
XA/57/40, A/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
840/1998, Gborie et al.A/56/40 |
XA/57/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
841/1998, Sesay et al.A/56/40 |
XA/57/40, A/59/40 |
X |
|||||
|
South Africa (1) |
1818/2008, McCallumA/66/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
Spain (25) |
493/1992, GriffinA/50/40 |
XA/59/40, A/58/40 |
X |
||||
|
526/1993, HillA/52/40 |
XA/53/40, A/56/40, A/58/40, A/59/40, A/60/40, A/61/40, A/64/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
701/1996, Gómez VásquezA/55/40 |
XA/56/40, A/57/40, A/58/40, A/60/40, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
864/1999, Ruiz AgudoA/58/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
986/2001, SemeyA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/60/40, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1006/2001, MuñozA/59/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1007/2001, Sineiro FernandoA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/60/40, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1073/2002, Terón JesúsA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1095/2002, GomarizA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1101/2002, Alba CabriadaA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1104/2002, Martínez FernándezA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1122/2002, Lagunas CastedoA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1211/2003, OliveróA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1325/2004, Conde A/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1332/2004, Garcia et al.A/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1351 and 1352/2005, Hens and CorujoA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1363/2005, Gayoso MartínezA/65/40 |
XA/66/40, A/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1364/2005, CarpinteroA/64/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1381/2005, HachuelA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1473/2006, Morales Tornel,A/64/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of unsatisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/66/40, A/68/40 |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
1493/2006, Williams LecraftA/64/40 Case was closed during the ninety-ninth session, in the light of the measures taken by the State party (A/66/40). |
XA/65/40, A/66/40 |
||||||
|
1531/2006 Cunillera AriasA/66/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1945/2010, AchabalA/68/40 CCPR/C/111/D/2008/2010 Aarrass |
X |
||||||
|
Sri Lanka (15) |
916/2000, JayawardenaA/57/40 |
XA/58/40, A/59/40, A/60/40, A/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
950/2000, SarmaA/58/40 |
XA/59/40, A/60/40, A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
909/2000, KankanamgeA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1033/2001, NallaratnamA/59/40 |
XA/60/40, A/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1189/2003, FernandoA/60/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1249/2004, Immaculate Joseph et al.A/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1250/2004, RajapakseA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1373/2005, DissanakyeA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1376/2005, BandaranayakeA/63/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1406/2005, Weerawanza,A/64/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1426/2005, Dingiri BandaA/63/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1432/2005, GunaratnaA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1436/2005, SathasivamA/63/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1862/2009, Pathmini Peiris et al.A/67/40 CCPR/C/113/D/2087/2011, Guneththige |
X |
||||||
|
Suriname (8) |
146/1983, BaboeramTwenty-fourth sessionc |
XA/51/40, A/52/40,A/53/40, A/55/40, A/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
148 to 154/1983, Kamperveen,Riedewald, Leckie, Demrawsingh, Sohansingh, Rahman, HoostTwenty-fourth sessionc |
XA/51/40, A/52/40,A/53/40, A/55/40, A/61/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Sweden (3) |
1416/2005, AlzeryA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
||||
|
1833/2008, X.A/67/40 Follow-up dialogue was closed with a note of satisfactory implementation of the recommendation (A/69/40). |
XA/68/40 |
A/68/40 |
|||||
|
2149/2012, IslamA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
Tajikistan (22) |
964/2001, SaidovA/59/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
XA/60/40, A/62/40, A/67/40 |
|||||
|
973/2001, KhalilovaA/60/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
XA/60/40, A/62/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
985/2001, AliboevA/61/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI). |
A/62/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1042/2002, BoimurudovA/61/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/62/40, A/63/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1044/2002, NazrievA/61/40 |
XA/62/40, A/63/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1096/2002, KurbonovA/59/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
A/59/40, A/60/40, A/62/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1108 and 1121/2002, Karimov, Askarov and DavlatovA/62/40 The Committee decided to close the follow-up dialogue concerning the case of Mr. A. Davlatov and to suspend the dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation, concerning Mr. Karimov, Mr. Askarov and Mr. N. Davlatov (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/63/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1117/2002, KhomidovaA/59/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/60/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1195/2003, DunaevA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1200/2003, SattorovaA/64/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/65/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1208/2003, B. KurbanovA/61/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/62/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1209/2003, 1231/2003 and 1241/2004, Rakhmatov, Safarov and Salimov andMukhammadievA/63/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/67/40 |
||||||
|
1263/2004 and 1264/2004, Khuseynov and ButaevA/64/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/65/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1276/2004, IdievA/64/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/65/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1348/2005, AshurovA/62/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/67/40 |
||||||
|
1401/2005, KirpoA/65/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
1499/2006, IskandarovA/66/40 |
|||||||
|
1519/2006, KhostikoevA/65/40 The Committee decided to suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of its recommendation (see A/67/40, chap. VI) |
XA/66/40, A/67/40 |
||||||
|
Togo (4) |
422 to 424/1990, Aduayom et al.A/51/40 |
XA/56/40, A/57/40 |
X |
||||
|
505/1992, AcklaA/51/40 |
XA/56/40, A/57/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Trinidad and Tobago (23) |
232/1987, PintoA/45/40and 512/1992, PintoA/51/40 |
XA/51/40, A/52/40, A/53/40 |
X |
||||
|
362/1989, SoogrimA/48/40 |
XA/51/40, A/52/40A/53/40, A/58/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
434/1990, SeerattanA/51/40 |
XA/51/40, A/52/40, A/53/40 |
X |
|||||
|
523/1992, NeptuneA/51/40 |
XA/51/40, A/52/40A/53/40, A/58/40 |
X |
|||||
|
533/1993, ElahieA/52/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
554/1993, La VendeA/53/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
555/1993, BickarooA/53/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
569/1996, MathewsA/43/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
580/1994, AshbyA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
594/1992, PhillipA/54/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
672/1995, SmartA/53/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
677/1996, TeesdaleA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
683/1996, WanzaA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
684/1996, SahadathA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
721/1996, BoodooA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
752/1997, HenryA/54/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
818/1998, SextusA/56/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
845/1998, KennedyA/57/40 |
XA/58/40 |
X |
|||||
|
899/1999, Francis et al.A/57/40 |
XA/58/40 |
X |
|||||
|
908/2000, EvansA/58/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
928/2000, SooklalA/57/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
938/2000, Siewpersaud et al.A/59/40 |
XA/51/40,A/53/40 |
X |
|||||
|
Turkey (2) |
1853/2008 and 1854/2008, Atasoy and SarkutA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||
|
Turkmenistan (7) |
1450/2006, KomarovskyA/63/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
1460/2006, YklymovaA/64/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1530/2006, BozbeyA/66/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1883/2009, OrazovaA/67/40 CCPR/C/112/D/2069/2011, Shikhmuradov CCPR/C/113/D/2079/2011, Khadzhiev CCPR/C/113/D/2218/2012, Abdullayev |
X X X |
||||||
|
Ukraine (5) |
781/1997, AlievA/58/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
||||
|
1405/2005, PustovoitA/69/40 |
X |
||||||
|
1412/2005, ButovenkoA/66/40 |
X |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
1535/2006, ShchetkaA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1803/2008, BulgakovA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
Uruguay (39) |
A.[5/1977, MasseraSeventh session43/1979, CaldasNineteenth session63/1979, AntonaccioFourteenth session73/1980, IzquierdoFifteenth session80/1980, VasiliskisEighteenth session83/1981, MachadoTwentieth session84/1981, Dermit BarbatoSeventeenth session85/1981, RomeroTwenty-first session88/1981, BequioEighteenth session92/1981, NietoNineteenth session103/1981, ScaroneTwentieth session105/1981, CabreiraNineteenth session109/1981, VoituretTwenty-first session123/1982, LluberasTwenty-first session] |
X43 follow-up repliesreceived A/59/40i |
X |
||||
|
B.[103/1981, Scarone73/1980, Izquierdo92/1981, Nieto85/1981, Romero] |
|||||||
|
C.[63/1979, Antonaccio80/1980, Vasiliskis123/1982, Lluberas] |
|||||||
|
D.[4/1977, RamirezFourth session6/1977, SequeiroSixth session25/1978, MassiottiSixteenth session28/1978, WeiszEleventh session32/1978, TouronTwelfth session 33/1978, CarballalTwelfth session37/1978, De BostonTwelfth session44/1979, PietraroiaTwelfth session52/1979, Lopez BurgosThirteenth session56/1979, CelibertiThirteenth session66/1980, SchweizerSeventeenth session70/1980, SimonesFifteenth session74/1980, EstrellaEighteenth session110/1981, VianaTwenty-first session139/1983, ConterisTwenty-fifth session147/1983, GilboaTwenty-sixth session162/1983, AcostaThirty-fourth session] |
|||||||
|
E.[30/1978, BleierFifteenth session84/1981, Dermit BarbatoSeventeenth session107/1981, QuinterosNineteenth session] |
|||||||
|
159/1983, CariboniA/43/40c |
X |
X |
|||||
|
322/1988, RodríguezA/51/40, A/49/40 |
XA/51/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1887/2009, Peirano BassoA/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||||
|
1637/2007, 1757/2008, and 1765/2008, Canessa Albareda et al.A/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
||||||
|
Uzbekistan (32) |
907/2000, SiragevA/61/40 |
XA/61/40 |
X |
||||
|
911/2000, NazarovA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
915/2000, RuzmetovA/61/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
917/2000, ArutyunyanA/59/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
931/2000, HudoyberganovaA/60/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
959/2000, BazarovA/61/40 |
XA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
|||||
|
971/2001, ArutyuniantzA/60/40 |
XA/60/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1017/2001, Strakhov and 1066/2002, FayzulaevA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1041/2002, Tulayganov A/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1043/2002, ChikiunovA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1057/2002, KorvetovA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
XA/62/40 |
|||||
|
1071/2002, AgabekovA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1140/2002, KhudayberganovA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1150/2002, UteevA/63/40 |
XA/64/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1163/2003, Isaev and KarimovA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1225/2003, EshonovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1280/2004, TolipkhudzhaevA/64/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1284/2004, KodirovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1334/2004, Mavlonov and Sa’diA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1378/2005, KasimovA/64/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1382/2005, SalikhA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1418/2005, IskiyaevA/64/40 |
XA/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1449/2006, UmarovA/66/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1478/2006, KungurovA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1552/2007, LyashkevichA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1585/2007, BatyrovA/64/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1589/2007, GapirjanovA/65/40 |
XA/66/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1769/2008, IsmailovA/66/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1914-1915-1916/2009, MusaevA/67/40 |
XA/68/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
Venezuela (BolivarianRepublic of) (3) |
156/1983, SolórzanoA/41/40c |
XA/59/40 |
X |
||||
|
1940/2010, CedeñoA/68/40 |
X |
||||||
|
CCPR/C/112/D/2085/2011 García Bolívar |
X |
||||||
|
Zambia (6) |
390/1990, LubutoA/51/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
X |
|||
|
821/1998, ChongweA/56/40 |
XA/56/40, A/57/40, A/59/40, A/61/40, A/64/40, A/66/40 |
XA/68/40 |
|||||
|
856/1999, ChambalaA/58/40 |
XA/62/40 |
X |
X |
||||
|
1132/2002, ChisangaA/61/40 |
XA/61/40, A/63/40, A/64/40, A/65/40 |
X |
|||||
|
1303/2004, ChitiA/68/40 |
X |
X |
|||||
|
1859/2009, KamoyoA/67/40 |
X |
X |
a See Selected Decisions of the Human Rights Committee under the Optional Protocol (vol. 1) (United Nations publication, Sales No. E.84.XIV.2).
b The State party went some way to implementing the Views: the Committee has not specifically said implementation is satisfactory.
c See Selected Decisions of the Human Rights Committee under the Optional Protocol (vol. 2) (United Nations publication, Sales No. E.89.XIV.1).
dFor all of these property cases, see also follow-up to concluding observations for the State party’s reply in A/59/40.
eSee A/59/40 for details of follow-up consultations.
fThe State party has not replied in writing, but it has met several times with the Special Rapporteur.
g See A/59/40. Twenty-five detailed replies were received, of which 19 indicated that the State party would not implement the Committee’s recommendations; in 2, that it would investigate; in 1, that the author would be released (592/1994, Clive Johnson; see A/54/40). There were 36 general replies indicating that death sentences had been commuted. There were no follow-up replies in 31 cases.
h According to the information provided in A/52/40, the author had been released. No further has been information provided.
i Follow-up information was provided on 17 October 1991 (unpublished). Regarding the list of cases under A, the State party submitted that, on 1 March 1985, the competence of the civil courts was re-established. The amnesty law of 8 March 1985 benefited all the individuals who had been involved as authors, accomplices or accessory participants in political crimes or crimes committed for political purposes, from 1 January 1962 to 1 March 1985. The law allowed those individuals held responsible for intentional murder to have either their conviction reviewed or their sentence reduced. Pursuant to article 10 of the Act on National Pacification, all the individuals imprisoned under “measures of security” were released. In cases subjected to review, appellate courts either acquitted or condemned the individuals. By virtue of Act 15.783 of 20 November, all the individuals who had previously held a public office were entitled to return to their jobs. On cases under B, the State party indicates that these individuals were pardoned by virtue of Act 15.737 and released on 10 March 1985. Regarding the list of cases under C, these individuals were released on 14 March 1985; their cases were included under Act 15.737. Regarding the list of cases under D, from 1 March 1985, the possibility to file an action for damages was open to all of the victims of human rights violations that occurred during the de facto government. Since 1985, 36 suits for damages have been filed, 22 of them for arbitrary detention and 12 for the return of property. The Government settled Mr. Lopez’s case on 21 November 1990 by paying him $200,000. The suit filed by Lilian Celiberti is still pending. Besides the aforementioned cases, no other victim has filed a lawsuit against the State claiming compensation. Regarding the list of cases under E, on 22 December 1986 the Congress passed Act 15.848, known as “termination of public prosecutions”. Under the Act, the State can no longer prosecute crimes committed before 1 March 1985 by the military or the police for political ends or on orders received from their superiors. All pending proceedings were discontinued. On 16 April 1989, the Act was confirmed by referendum. The Act required investigating judges to send reports submitted to the judiciary about victims of disappearances to the Government, for the latter to initiate inquiries.